Marvel Denies the Shield to Will Smith - Captain America Rumor Debunked

Yesterday, a fairly obvious rumor was started that Will Smith had been tapped to star as our favorite star-spangled superhero. Now that rumor has been debunked by Marvel itself.

By ComicBookMovie - Sep 09, 2008 12:09 AM EST

Filed Under: Captain America: The First Avenger

Here is what the original MTV article said...

When Marvel announced that “Captain America” was making its way to the big-screen, fans everywhere began speculating who would be donning the famous red-white-and-blue tights. Nothing has been heard since, but during an MTV News interview regarding his role in “Miracle at St. Anna,” actor Derek Luke let slip that a very prominent - and surprising - face could be the star of Marvel Studios’ next blockbuster film.

“I heard they offered Will Smith ‘Captain America,’” said Luke, adding that the intriguing casting rumor “just shows you how times have changed.”

Harry Knowles of AICN was the first to contact Marvel directly to get their straight talk...

Multiple sources from MARVEL have confirmed that Derek Luke, of Spike Lee's MIRACLE AT ST. ANNA, doesn't know what he's talking about when it comes to Will Smith and CAPTAIN AMERICA. Marvel never offered the part, nor did they approach or entertain a conversation about Will Smith for CAPTAIN AMERICA. That said - I'm sure they have a few parts that they'd like him for, just not Captain America. So there ya go. They haven't gone insane and we don't need to be confused, angry and scared about it anymore.

I'm sure Harry isn't trying to be racist by inferring his distaste for Will in the role of Steve. Pretty much EVERYONE likes Will Smith. But while more "minor" characters can withstand a race or even a sex/gender makeover (I'm thinking Nick Fury, BSG's Starbuck, even GAY Colossus) there are others that fans won't tolerate. Even Will Smith himself is quoted as saying that he'd turned down the role of Superman because he didn't think a black man of steel would fly. A race-revamp in such iconic characters like Supes and Captain America would cause a bit of geek consternation--to put it lightly. If you don't believe it, just imagine the backlash if Marvel decided to do a Black Panther movie with some really white guy in the starring role. It is much safer, and easily acceptable to simply create an all-new character in the same vein--such as the African-American Green Lantern John Stewart, who was created as a politically correct "token" character until his character was made to shine in the animated Justice League cartoon.

What are YOUR thoughts? Would Will Smith have made a decent Captain America? Or, would that color change be just a little too much for the character to remain the same in your mind. Let us know your thoughts by voting.

THE FRANCHISE: Trailer For Max Series Starring Daniel Brühl Reveals Chaos Inside World Of Superhero Filmmaking

Recommended For You:

THE SHIFT Star Neal McDonough Talks Possible MCU Return As CAPTAIN AMERICA's Dum Dum Dugan (Exclusive)

DISCLAIMER: ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and... [MORE]

ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

Do you have what it takes to write for us?

Want to contribute?

Marvel Denies the Shield to Will Smith - Captain America Rumor Debunked

Yesterday, a fairly obvious rumor was started that Will Smith had been tapped to star as our favorite star-spangled superhero. Now that rumor has been debunked by Marvel itself.

THE FRANCHISE: Trailer For Max Series Starring Daniel Brühl Reveals Chaos Inside World Of Superhero Filmmaking

THE SHIFT Star Neal McDonough Talks Possible MCU Return As CAPTAIN AMERICA's Dum Dum Dugan (Exclusive)

THE SHIFT Star Neal McDonough Talks Possible MCU Return As CAPTAIN AMERICA's Dum Dum Dugan (Exclusive)

STAR TREK: DISCOVERY Star Ethan Peck Reveals He Auditioned For Lead Role In CAPTAIN AMERICA: THE FIRST AVENGER

THE FALCON AND THE WINTER SOLDIER Star Sebastian Stan Recalls The Moment He Thought His Time As Bucky Was Over

THE SHIFT Star Neal McDonough Talks Possible MCU Return As CAPTAIN AMERICA's Dum Dum Dugan (Exclusive)

STAR TREK: DISCOVERY Star Ethan Peck Reveals He Auditioned For Lead Role In CAPTAIN AMERICA: THE FIRST AVENGER

THE FALCON AND THE WINTER SOLDIER Star Sebastian Stan Recalls The Moment He Thought His Time As Bucky Was Over

MARVEL CINEMATIC UNIVERSE: 13 Heartbreaking Scenes That Made Fans Cry

CAPTAIN AMERICA: THE FIRST AVENGER Nearly Featured A Battle With A Giant Red Skull-Controlled Robot

AVENGERS: ENDGAME And CAPTAIN AMERICA Writers Argue That MCU's Steve Rogers Is NOT A Virgin

Popular Headlines

SPIDER-MAN: Some Big Changes Are Supposedly Being Made To Marvel Studios' Deal With Sony Pictures

LANTERNS: Kyle Chandler Set To Play Hal Jordan In DCU Series

THUNDERBOLTS* Trailer May Finally Solve The Yearslong Mystery About Avengers Tower's New Owner - SPOILERS

THUNDERBOLTS* Official Trailer And Poster Assemble The MCU's Least Anticipated Band Of Misfits

THUNDERBOLTS* Trailer Breakdown: 7 Biggest Reveals And Possible Spoilers In The Action-Packed Teaser

X-MEN '97: New Report Reveals When The Show Will Return To Disney+ With Season 2

THE BOYS Adds HAMILTON And SNOWPIERCER Star Daveed Diggs In Mystery Role

JOKER: FOLIE À DEUX Director Believes Joker Would Be In Awe Of Batman; Lady Gaga Announces Companion Album

X-MEN '97: New Report Reveals When The Show Will Return To Disney+ With Season 2

THE BOYS Adds HAMILTON And SNOWPIERCER Star Daveed Diggs In Mystery Role

JOKER: FOLIE À DEUX Director Believes Joker Would Be In Awe Of Batman; Lady Gaga Announces Companion Album

THUNDERBOLTS* Poster Detail Leads To Speculation That Marvel Used AI To Create The Image

THUNDERBOLTS* Trailer Reveals Sentry Twist And Potential Plans To Make Shocking Addition To Avengers Tower

STORM Teams Up With More Of The Marvel Universe's Greatest Superheroes On Electrifying Variant Covers

Hot Headlines

LANTERNS: Kyle Chandler Set To Play Hal Jordan In DCU Series

THUNDERBOLTS* Official Trailer And Poster Assemble The MCU's Least Anticipated Band Of Misfits

THUNDERBOLTS* Poster Detail Leads To Speculation That Marvel Used AI To Create The Image

AGATHA ALL ALONG Poll Results: Find Out What CBM Readers Made Of The First Two Episodes

BEETLEJUICE BEETLEJUICE Remains At The Top Of Domestic Box Office As TRANSFORMERS ONE Underperforms

Sci-Fi & Fantasy

THE LORD OF THE RINGS: THE WAR OF THE ROHIRRIM - First Poster For Female-Led Animated Prequel Revealed

STAR WARS: Daisy Ridley Says New Movie Has A Story "Worth Telling" As Rumors Swirl About The Its Status

UNDERWORLD Star Rhona Mitra Teases Role In Upcoming RED SONJA Remake: "[I] Kick Some Arse"

Cartoons & Animated Features

X-MEN '97: Beau DeMayo Explains Why The Finale Featured T'Chaka As Black Panther Instead Of T'Challa

THE LORD OF THE RINGS: THE WAR OF THE ROHIRRIM - Check Out The First Poster For Animated Prequel

TRANSFORMERS ONE Spoilers: Here's What Happens During The Movie's Ending And Post-Credits Scenes

Gaming

RUMOR: Rocksteady Studios May Be Working On A PS5-Exclusive BATMAN Game Following The ARKHAM Trilogy

MARVEL RIVALS Reveals Psylocke As Newest Playable Character

TALES OF THE SHIRE: A LORD OF THE RINGS GAME Announces Release Date

Anime & Manga

MY HAPPY MARRIAGE Season 2 Returning January 2025; New Teaser Trailer And Key Visual Released

DANDADAN Shares English Dub Trailer Ahead Of October Premiere

JUJUTSU KAISEN Teases "More To Come" After Anime Ends Next Week

Horror

BARBARIAN Director Zach Cregger Rumored To Be Lining Up New RESIDENT EVIL Movie At Sony

SINNERS: Posters For Ryan Coogler's Vampire Movie Reveal First Look At Michael B. Jordan's Character(s)

SINNERS: Warner Bros. Unveils Official Title And Teaser For Ryan Coogler's Vampire Movie

Action Movies & TV

GLADIATOR II Poster And Trailer Pit Paul Mescal's Lucius Against Pedro Pascal's Marcus Acacius

RED ONE: New Trailer Sends Chris Evans & Dwayne Johnson On A High Stakes Mission To Save Santa

TOMB RAIDER: THE LEGEND OF LARA CROFT Trailer Released, Featuring Hayley Atwell On A Global Quest

Pro Wrestling & MMA News

Janel Grant's Lawyer Responds To Vince McMahon's MR. MCMAHON Claims As New Details Emerge About Netflix Deal

Jey Uso Wins His First Singles Title On RAW As Rhea Ripley vs. Liv Morgan At BAD BLOOD Gets Crazy Stipulation

Vince McMahon Issues Statement About MR. MCMAHON Documentary: Claims It Features A "Deceptive Narrative"

Sci-Fi & Fantasy

THE LORD OF THE RINGS: THE WAR OF THE ROHIRRIM - First Poster For Female-Led Animated Prequel Revealed

STAR WARS: Daisy Ridley Says New Movie Has A Story "Worth Telling" As Rumors Swirl About The Its Status

UNDERWORLD Star Rhona Mitra Teases Role In Upcoming RED SONJA Remake: "[I] Kick Some Arse"

AVATAR Director James Cameron Hits Back At Critics Who Complain About The "Cringe" Dialogue In His Movies

TERMINATOR: DARK FATE Producer James Cameron Thinks The Movie Is "Cracking" But Knows Where It Went Wrong

GLADIATOR II Gets An Action-Packed, Epic New Trailer And Poster As Ridley Scott Pulls Out All The Stops

Cartoons & Animated Features

X-MEN '97: Beau DeMayo Explains Why The Finale Featured T'Chaka As Black Panther Instead Of T'Challa

THE LORD OF THE RINGS: THE WAR OF THE ROHIRRIM - Check Out The First Poster For Animated Prequel

TRANSFORMERS ONE Spoilers: Here's What Happens During The Movie's Ending And Post-Credits Scenes

X-MEN '97: Fired Showrunner Beau DeMayo Addresses Storm And Sunspot Whitewashing Controversy

New ARCANE Season 2 Trailer Packs A Punch As Netflix Reveals Release Date

TOMB RAIDER: THE LEGEND OF LARA CROFT Trailer Released; Hayley Atwell Leads Action-Packed Adventure Series

Gaming

RUMOR: Rocksteady Studios May Be Working On A PS5-Exclusive BATMAN Game Following The ARKHAM Trilogy

MARVEL RIVALS Reveals Psylocke As Newest Playable Character

TALES OF THE SHIRE: A LORD OF THE RINGS GAME Announces Release Date